I watched the premiere of “1 vs. 100″ with Bob Saget last night and I have to say it’s better than “Deal or No Deal” for a number of reasons.
1. Winning actually requires knowledge
Unlike “Deal” in which you just pick a suitcase and hold onto it until you chicken out, “1 vs. 100″ requires you to have a level of cultural literacy. For example, some questions involved the Venus de Milo, the earth’s mantel, and a perfect credit score. I tend to like game shows where contestants need to think to succeed and not simply have blind luck.
2. Bob Saget is less annoying
Bob Saget has previously hosted “America’s Funniest Home Videos” but this is a little different. Still, he had a quick wit when contestants and members of the mob made verbal slips. Howie Mandel’s transitions to commercials are just plain cheesy. Also, Saget has more hair on his head.
3. It has a better catchphrase
“The money or the mob” just sounds better than “deal or no deal” and might have a little more staying power than “is that your final answer?” or “you’re fired!”
4. There is a variety of faces
After each contestant leaves, those in the mob who missed questions are replaced by new people while those who scored perfect that round stay. This puts in new blood and more chances to say things like “we have 9 teachers (or 7 surfers) in the mob”.
5. It flows faster
There’s no silhouetted banker making offers or families trying to tell you to take the money. Instead there is only you, the mob, and Saget. Well, and the studio audience of course.
Fourteen questions were asked in 42 minutes; that’s about three minutes per question asked. Then again, since this was the first episode and the rules had to be explained, I would guess the average is closer to 2:30 per question which is fast recalling how long some people took on “Millionaire” to answer questions using lifelines and thinking out loud.

Alas, the show isn’t perfect. Twice, there were plugs within the show for the one that airs before it. You guessed it, “Deal or No Deal”. The first instance was three “briefcase girls” in the first mob; the second was within a question involving how many numbers on the 26 briefcases used on the show are evenly divisible by 3. Believe it or not, 18 out of the remaining 65 mob-mates (28%) missed this basic math question, netting the contestant $36,000.

Another mistake came within a question about slang. It was “In contemporary slang, what would you do with your ‘badunkadunk’?” Anyone who has watched Chappelle’s Show knows that the proper word is “badonkadonk”. Even Google offers a different spelling when you type it in.

Just another instance of NBC failing at trying to be hip, I suppose.
By the way, Mr. Chappelle was the answer to a previous question about who walked away from a $50 million deal with Comedy Central.
